I was asked this AM if it was ethical for an Audiologist to accept a trip from a vendor. In my opinion it is only ethical if you don't buy from that vendor. Take the trip, and then buy from someone else and I would think you are Ok.
I don't profess to be an Audiologist ethics expert, and below I have posted links to the ethics pages for AAA, ADA, and ASHA. In addition there is anti-kickback language in most third party reimbursement contracts including Medicare and Medicaid that if you participate in these programs impact you.
This isn't an ethics violation on the part of the supplier. They can attempt almost any legal sales technique they think might work. Many things are legal, that are not ethical. That is why professional groups have codes of ethics; to limit actions that are legal, but not consistent with the profession.
It is the Audiologist that wants to tell people they uphold a higher standard, not the vendor. The vendors sell hearing aids to non-Audiologists this way and in other parts of the world this way. Non-Audiologists and people in other countries have different ethical situations.
One supplier told me (on a flight from a conference) that they don't think it is ethical for Audiologists, but it isn't their problem. She indicated in her opinion that the way to get an Audiologist's attention and influence them is to buy them a vacation. Cheap and effective marketing as she saw it.
Just because "everyone" does it doesn't make it right. Would you accept your child's explaining the speeding ticket, while legally drunk, driving your car, as OK because everyone who left the party was doing it?
And then there is the professional reality test:
If you would be comfortable sitting in front of a patient as you are explaining to them what it will cost to purchase their hearing aid and disclosing how you were influenced.
It might sound something like this:
" You might want to know that the supplier I use to acquire these hearing aids paid for a couple of vacations for me to Mexico (Hawaii, Vegas, Bermuda, anywhere that sounds like a vacation spot) and while I was their guest I decided they would be the company I would use. I also expect if I sell enough of their hearing aids I will again be rewarded with another all expense paid vacation. "
Now that test doesn't relate to the written third party contracts or the professional ethics standards, but it might be the most reflective.
Ethics Links:
ASHA http://www.asha.org/docs/html/ET2003-00166.html
AAA: http://dev.aaa.susqtech.com/publications/documents/ethics/default.htm
ADA: http://www.audiologist.org/resources/documents/professionals/Code_of_Ethics.pdf
